If I had to rate Dead Space 3, I would give it a 9.5/10.
You are what's wrong with the gaming industry.
You know what games like Dead Space 3 and Crysis 3 and Battlefield 3 and Modern Warfare 3 are? They're blockbusters.
They're big dumb action films, calculated to appeal to our most base satisfaction. They cost millions of dollars to make and market, but ultimately they're nothing more than shooting things and looking at pretty sights.
There's no artistic ambition, there's no innovation, there's nothing but a formula and production values. These are games the industry makes in their sleep, and they simply cannot fail. They have an inbuilt audience.
That's because the gamer and game critic aren't like the moviegoer and the movie critic, for instance. The gamer still doesn't take games seriously. The gamer will seriously give a stupid, boneheaded FPS a grade like 9.5, meaning near-perfection, because he simply doesn't see what games
could be.
The movie critic looks at an action film and sees the cliché, the formulas, the blandness and cheap emotional appeal, and judges the movie accordingly.
Of course, it's no use criticizing a Hollywood film for being artless. If it just wants to be fun and IS a lot of fun, great! It does what it sets out to do. But nobody ever treats Fast & Furious 6 as a masterpiece of cinema. Nobody gives it a perfect score, because that's stupid. Movies can do far more than that, and to call a movie that aims so low "
erfect" is to underestimate the entire medium.
But the gaming critic, he just doesn't see that potential in games. He will give a near-perfect score to Black Ops II because it's "cinematic" and "fun" and "awesome" and "big", as if that's everything a game could ever hope to be.
It is downright astonishing that titles as profound and inventive and well-written as BioShock, Portal, Planescape: Torment, Deus Ex and whatever the **** even exist, because from the way reviewers expect freaking nothing from games, it's like they don't. It's like nobody knows games can be more.
Dead Space 3, game of the year, 9.5/10?
Fat. ****ing. Chance.