I thought it was great. The only thing I really didn't like about it though were its fight sequences. The new thing in Hollywood is to shake the camera a fuck ton when anything is happening in a fight scene. That got kind of annoying and they did jack the T-rex (from Jurassic Parks) voice and lower it for the snow monster that attacked captain kirk. It had a great use of the old catch phrases and didn't overly do it, and the way the characters were introduced fit perfectly. It sets it up as an alternate time line prequel so it doesn't really ruin anything the hardcore fans would like about the other movies. Yet it is still for the casual trek fan as well over all I would probably give it a b+
i thought it wasnt bad (im not really a fan of the old ones and kinda think they sucked) i mean it wasnt a brilliant film but it was far better than i expected it too be
I have to admit... I am a trekkie (or trekker, whatever). I saw the movie recently and I thought it was good. I especially liked how they brought back stuff from old episodes. It was a lot of fun.