ForumsThe TavernWould you hit a woman...

204 25761
hellian00
offline
hellian00
874 posts
Nomad

in self defense? As in, she was attacking you and swinging full force blows. Could you bring yourself to hit her back?

I(believing strongly in gender equality) would have no problem hitting her back.

  • 204 Replies
Zedralan
offline
Zedralan
98 posts
Nomad

If it was melee against melee, with no weapons and no deciding factors I would not hit a woman. I was taught that and I will stick with it.


But if the woman had a heavy weapon, gun, or something like that I might fight back or at least try and defend myself.

In all seriousness it depends on the situation.

Xavier1
offline
Xavier1
671 posts
Nomad

Well, if you actually had any ability in reading comprehension you would note that I didn't say 'average woman' I said women - which includes those that are *not* average. I study Kung Fu with some seriously dangerous ladies, and I've also met women that are like friggin' amazons - they're around 6'4" and weigh like 240 lbs. of pure muscle & could overpower a lot of guys without breaking a sweat. Perhaps the next time you attempt to insult someone you should pay more attention.


But when making broad statements like I respect women. The only logical thing to do is look at the average. So it's still not a contradiction.
Strop
offline
Strop
10,816 posts
Bard

If Venus Williams was going to fight you... I'd GTFO


I'd be afraid of what I'd have done to provoke Venus into a fight with me in the first place.

In other news, my e-penor is thiiiiiiiiiiiiiiis biiiiiiiiiiig! I may not have any belts but I can do flips! Huh!? Huh!?!?

Well, since you guys are talking about TKD...let me be the first (but undoubtedly hardly the last) to say that unless you use TKD for what it was originally used for, and that would be knocking people off horses and barefisted kamikaze attacks against soldiers wearing 50lbs of armour, you're not going to do very well against somebody with at least a little fight experience. The movements come from a mile away. And the blocks center around taking the force of strong blows, but most of these, similarly, are useless in the face of most techniques. I also got admonished for blocking high kicks with my arms because they "would break", which is rubbish! Aaaaaand in the course of my studies, I've taken a liking to techniques you'd never use in TKD, partially because they don't go for the pads, partially because they'd be forbidden.

Which is why I would never intend to learn forms past yellow belt so I could enter local tournaments and have fun belting people in their armour pads.

Brazilian jujitsu


Now there's a form that does well in unrestricted martial arts tourneys. Usually combined with Muay Thai, because there's only so many elbows to the face 4000 years of heritage can take.
Xavier1
offline
Xavier1
671 posts
Nomad

I agree. TKD is fail. There was this kid who kept asking me to fight him because he had been doing TKD since he was 4 and so we went behind the woodwork building and I ended up beating him until he cried and I'm really nothing special at all.

I would never be game enough to fight someone who knows Brajillian Jujitsu. I saw some brazillian dude do a "flying armbar" on somebody in the UFC. It was scary.

Strop
offline
Strop
10,816 posts
Bard

Flying armbar ftw

I've seen a friend apply flying armbar in a Judo tourney actually, then, when the guy dropped, somehow got him into a bow-and-arrow hold- because the armbar alone wouldn't be enough to score ippon.

Brazilian jujitsu looks like fun, though I'm not a fan of grappling, though who knows, maybe the time spent with my brother counts for something. That said, I do like TKD. It was from the TKD kicking technique that I learnt to flyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy~

Ahhhh darn it, you guys made me waste an hour on youtube. Here's a...I don't know what to call this.

A modern take on taekwondo? Why is it that all the TKD videos on youtube seem to be either sub-par or thought of as sup-par? I don't know what the reference standard is but compared to the instructors at, say, my uni gym, (and myself) this guy's moving in slooooooooooow motion.

DDX
offline
DDX
3,562 posts
Nomad

I agree. TKD is fail. There was this kid who kept asking me to fight him because he had been doing TKD since he was 4 and so we went behind the woodwork building and I ended up beating him until he cried and I'm really nothing special at all.


TKD is for show, I do muay thai. Though Currently I am out for a 3 weeks due to a bone bruise. GOd tose elbows are painful..

Now there's a form that does well in unrestricted martial arts tourneys. Usually combined with Muay Thai, because there's only so many elbows to the face 4000 years of heritage can take.


1 sinking python will kill you. if not knock you out.
Strop
offline
Strop
10,816 posts
Bard

Everybody who is srs biznis about martial arts these days is doing muay thai >:

To stay on topic...if a woman was good at Muay Thai, I'd totally hit it xD

hellian00
offline
hellian00
874 posts
Nomad

I now like lead pipes~


I think anybody who has to use weapons (let alone poisonous ones) is a coward.
sonam
offline
sonam
840 posts
Nomad

well you mean hit her, then yeah

DDX
offline
DDX
3,562 posts
Nomad

To stay on topic...if a woman was good at Muay Thai, I'd totally hit it xD


Yea I'd hit that too

well you mean hit her, then yeah

he means sexual relations I believe.
Bugsy77
offline
Bugsy77
65 posts
Nomad

Well

To be honest If she were really to hit me...! Well i would probably try and pin her down but i wouldnt ...like kick her ass until her teeth fall out!

Bugsy77
offline
Bugsy77
65 posts
Nomad

Soz....Excuse the language....ive not been on the forums for like ages now...forgot about the rules... forgive me

napolian654321
offline
napolian654321
922 posts
Nomad

I haave respect for women and I don't hit them. UNLESS, they aboslutely lose their mind and attack the crap out of me I'll defend myself.

Zophia
offline
Zophia
9,424 posts
Scribe

abo****ely
Lol typo. XD

Well, I already have, so I can't really say no. Temper... Though I am usually more of a kicking person when it gets down to giving out hurtses.
Jabberwocky
offline
Jabberwocky
92 posts
Shepherd

in the wise words of ghandi: "an eye for an eye makes the whole world blind". fighting back would only result in guilt, regret, and likely more fighting later. i would try to calm her down, or just give her a hug. unexpected affection has solved similar situations many a time.

Showing 46-60 of 204