I agree, I really enjoyed the second one. The fact that some pieces can actually break makes crushing the castles a lot less cluttery. And of course, a large variety of weapons are there, even if some are VERY situational.
Second is no doubt better, more levels, more weapons, etc.
However, I must say, the first was more fun for it's time since it was such a novel idea. THis is like Sinjid vs Sonny 1 for me. Sonny is more streamlined and refined, but Sinjid was a novel idea for its time (2004) and thus I found it more surprisingly fun to play.
The second one is better of course. Quite some reasons for that...
Better graphics, more diversity, and probably more levels aswell. The option to build and play custumized levels is also a big plus.
This doesn't mean you have to enjoy part 2 more then part 1, because the first one was a new kind of game back then, and could therefore be extra exciting...
Definitely 2nd. It has better graphics, more weapons, harder castles, and the people don't die that easily. I like a challenge. And when I first used the black hole potion I went like, "WTF!" cause I had my volume on max.
joey should make an online one where you have to destroy the opponents launcher thing. No black hole though, that would be cheap.
Welll... Like both parts equally. The first one is easy and more enjoyable for me. The second part has more weapons, which is a good thing. But it still has a physics prblem. People can still be alive even when a whole castle fall on them. A thats the bad thing.