ForumsThe TavernIf you're born deaf what language do you think in?

33 8707
Crouchbite
offline
Crouchbite
219 posts
Nomad

I mean seriously this is been on my mind for awhile and I can't get it out.

  • 33 Replies
Cenere
offline
Cenere
13,657 posts
Jester

Actually, it was researched for a bit. Deaf people with no hearing at all will dream in sign language. From this I will conclude that deaf people, who have never required a verbally spoken language do not think in a verbally spoken language (obviously), nor do they think in a written one.
They could possibly think in written words as well, but it would be rare (just like when you have a moment of "oh, look, letters in my head&quot.

To conclude further, if a person is born hearing, but looses this ability during their first years/before they have gained a proper, whole vocabulary, they will most likely also think in sign language, as that would be the widest and therefore most usable language they are aware of.

Strop
offline
Strop
10,816 posts
Bard

To expand a bit on what Cenere has said, if you are born with no hearing or lose it early on, in what's called the critical stage of development, your auditory circuits in your cortex (the operational part of your brain) will simply fade away and get taken over by other parts that you do use. Thus you will theoretically be completely unable to respond, imagine, think of sound. I assume similar applies for sight and the other senses, though there is one notable case of a guy who went blind as a young man, and trained himself to continue "thinking visually", and it seems to work well for him: he has been known to work the tiling on his roof in the middle of the night!

theone99
offline
theone99
3,041 posts
Shepherd

i wanna link to the story (research Cenere is talking about) or This guy will come to your house and bang on your door!! *no spamming about this*

Cenere
offline
Cenere
13,657 posts
Jester

I have a short article on it, but it is in Danish, and I got the story from Sign language TV a year or so back.
I translated a bit here.

member565
offline
member565
102 posts
Nomad

It would be useful to get the answer from someone who is actually deaf

Google567
offline
Google567
4,013 posts
Farmer

I agree with the pictures and feelings.

member565
offline
member565
102 posts
Nomad

One thing about being born deaf is that you don't to worry about grammar much

zasgat
offline
zasgat
142 posts
Nomad

non deaf babies do not know how to speak any more than deaf babys

hidude1212
offline
hidude1212
336 posts
Nomad

i believe that somone born deaf would think in pictures and feelings but i may (and probably will) be wrong

Keonyama96
offline
Keonyama96
79 posts
Nomad

In all seriousness ask a doctor but the kid would not think in a specific language but as it grows and adds conections to things it probably thinks in the language the see the parents speak in

Cenere
offline
Cenere
13,657 posts
Jester

In all seriousness ask a doctor but the kid would not think in a specific language but as it grows and adds conections to things it probably thinks in the language the see the parents speak in

Note that Strop is half a year from being a doctor.

non deaf babies do not know how to speak any more than deaf babys

I believe this is about worded thoughts, which babies obviously will not have. However, because of this, the question is not about babies but about adult/older people, who are capable of worded thoughts.
Freakenstein
offline
Freakenstein
9,504 posts
Jester

Babies that can hear obviously will try to interpret what everyone is saying. Babies that are deaf have no languages to hear. In contrasting the two, it does not matter whether or not the babies can hear; they will both act and think on instinct as is their nature to do. I'm sure their curiosity clicks every now and then, but in other situations, their main objective as a newborn is to survive, sleep, and grow.

Keonyama96
offline
Keonyama96
79 posts
Nomad

Note that Strop is half a year from being a doctor.

I didn't know that and now i feel dumb for making the statement thank you very much
TuxedoPenguin
offline
TuxedoPenguin
233 posts
Nomad

I think that it would think it would speak whatever language it learned. Well i mean that it can still read and write words. it could also sound out words in its head. all though it sounds really hard to sound out something you don't know sounds like. I don't know.

bacobit
offline
bacobit
1,671 posts
Nomad

I once heard that babies cry because a need is not being met (why crack babies cry so much). But, what about deaf babies? They can't hear any noise, so they don't know if they're making noise or not. How would they express a need that is not being met?

Showing 16-30 of 33