Hmm haven't seen a topic like this before... first of all the wii DOES suck. They make all the good games look gay. example: Fifa 2010. For 360 you actually have a REAL looking player. Wii? hmm little people running around (with terrible quality) doesn't sound fun. And I know, Ive played it for both consoles. And how much has the Wii upgraded? none. They take good games and try to make them fun but almost all of them SUCK. Oh and one more thing about wii. STICK TO THE ARCADE GAMES. I swear cod on wii... worst idea ever. I think ive made my point. Going back to the topic, I think it's a really tough decision. I have played PS3 but not enough to know any good games. I have a 360 so I would probably pick Red Dead Redemption, or Halo 3. I really can't decide between the two...