ForumsArt, Music, and Writing[ans] are you peeps harsh with critiquing? =w=;;

8 3330
Esanx
offline
Esanx
41 posts
Nomad

Was thinking of posting a story or two, maybe some action and romance, or epic tales of betrayal, just curious though, will it get flamed if I do? e.o;;

  • 8 Replies
IcyIndia
offline
IcyIndia
1,344 posts
Nomad

Of course you won't get flamed! It's against the rules anywhere on AG, and people here at the AMW will definitely give you some CC.

ABarOfSoap
offline
ABarOfSoap
230 posts
Nomad

No, you won't. However, due to the overwhelming amount of self-threads here in the AMW section, you might not get that much feed-back.

Freakenstein
offline
Freakenstein
9,504 posts
Jester

I don't see why you would. If anyone did that 'round here, they'd be ban-slapped in the face. We need more stories in this forum. All I see nowadays are poetry and various art pieces.

As far as critiquing goes, I'm an honest guy. If a guy made a clear mistake or something that can definitely be improved, I'll say it. I don't think I'm as blunt and in-your-face as DV is....Either way, what is Constructive Criticism without a bit of clear statements that you need to improve in areas? Saying "I like it, good job!" defeats that purpose. I ain't harsh though.

master565
offline
master565
4,104 posts
Nomad

Depends on wether its good or not. If it's good, its usually followed by a lot of compliments. If it's bad, people usually won't comment and if they comment in an offensive or mean manner, report the comment (little red flag on the right of comment) and the moderators would remove it. So i say go for it, post your stories.

MoonFairy
offline
MoonFairy
3,386 posts
Shepherd

Basically it's yes and no.
If your stories are good, or show sign of promise, you will get more positive feedback.

If it is horrid, ( which it almost never is ) we will beat you into the ground with our opinions.

But you know, it is a 70% chance of good. So, take that chance.

Cenere
offline
Cenere
13,657 posts
Jester

If it is horrid, ( which it almost never is ) we will beat you into the ground with our opinions.

This here.
Basically, if you ask for critiques, you need to be able to take them, no matter how they come out.
However, throw me a link to this thread, if you think it is getting too much (some users here does not always know when to stop, this goes for both critics and writers), and try not to argue with people about petty things like that.
It is a take it or leave it deal.

Also, because it is a common misconception, and I am tired of seeing it:
report the comment (little red flag on the right of comment) and the moderators would remove it.

If it is offensive or mean, go to a mod. Don't just click on the flag, because then your problem does not get solve.
Not before AG, at least.
So, you are being abused, go to a mod. If you are abusing others, I count on them being just as smart, keep their tail clean, and go to a mod.
Remember: Arguing drags yourself into the mud. When both you and your opponent are covered in mud, mods are not going to play "favourites".

In short: Be nice, blahblahblahblah, report offenses to mod, blahblahblahblah.
Esanx
offline
Esanx
41 posts
Nomad

=w= I think I will post a story then! It'll be a short story, I'll post the thread. XD

DustyLee
offline
DustyLee
216 posts
Nomad

just go for it ! its easy tell tell the comments that are people who just are being jerks and the ones that you should seriously consider. alot of people would like to hear your stuff to

Showing 1-8 of 8