ForumsGamesPokemon SoulSilver or HeartGold

91 14831
dnguyen
offline
dnguyen
614 posts
Nomad

What do you think it's better.

Pokemon HeartGold

or

Pokemon SoulSilver

  • 91 Replies
dnguyen
offline
dnguyen
614 posts
Nomad

I prefer Lugia, always have, though Ho-Oh is still cool. The Lugia statue was cooler to me so I bought SoulSilver instead of HeartGold, and am too lazy to buy the other =P.


Same thing here, I thought the Ho-oh would be better, but LUGIA IS AWESOME!!!
deadhead50
offline
deadhead50
341 posts
Nomad

im too poor to buy either of them, and i kinda quit playing pokemon cuz everyone i played my friend with beat me > FREAKIN ACTION REPLAY THING!!!

dnguyen
offline
dnguyen
614 posts
Nomad

im too poor to buy either of them, and i kinda quit playing pokemon cuz everyone i played my friend with beat me > FREAKIN ACTION REPLAY THING!!!


Well, my friend quited Pokemon becuase I hacked. Yay LEGENDARIES!!!
cingcon
offline
cingcon
152 posts
Nomad

i dont know who said that ho ho is exclusive to gold but its not true. i have the original silver version and i was able to obtain lugia and ho ho without cheating. so what about crystal? i want a crystal remake

dnguyen
offline
dnguyen
614 posts
Nomad

i dont know who said that ho ho is exclusive to gold but its not true. i have the original silver version and i was able to obtain lugia and ho ho without cheating. so what about crystal? i want a crystal remake


You know what, that could be awesome. With the crystal remake, it'll be FUN!!!
CubeAddict420
offline
CubeAddict420
162 posts
Nomad

I like souls silver just bc I think lugia is coller than ho-oh, I mean, a dragon or a bird? ^^ Exaggeration

FallenSky
offline
FallenSky
1,813 posts
Peasant

Well I prefer Gold but this old pokemon connoisseur here doesn't love it for the same reasons as you folks ^^
This thread seems to be more of a debate as to which is best between Ho-oH and Lugia lol...
Now why do I prefer gold - or heartgold - is because of the exclusive pokemons. (Pokemons you can get only by trading)
In this case we're talking 'bout crap like bellsprout and growlithe but still, an oldschool gamer like me hate your overpowering tactics; I gladly go by Karen's ''discour'' ^^
(By overpowering I mean young'uns who build teams out of legendaries and pseudo-legendaries pokemon only...booooring!)
So yeah, I'd say heartgold because I can have a godblessed Victreebel without trading, hurray!
Now I say something that looked like this earlier:
Groudon>Kyogre
Now please explain that to me out of objective arguments.

dnguyen
offline
dnguyen
614 posts
Nomad

So yeah, I'd say heartgold because I can have a godblessed Victreebel without trading, hurray!
Now I say something that looked like this earlier:
Groudon>Kyogre
Now please explain that to me out of objective arguments.


First, I agree, but Groudon is so suckish with his defense. Kyogre is better.

Groudon<Kyogre
FallenSky
offline
FallenSky
1,813 posts
Peasant

You're totally right: as I said, this was posted earlier in the thread and it kind of bugged me.
Another reason why I prefer HeartGold is that because they made a cleavage in the moves (physical/special), sacred fire has become a physical attack whereas aeroblast is now a special one.
The thing is: Ho-oh can use a move fueled by attack way more efficiently than lugia use a move who needs SpAttack, thus, even though they have the same BaP, Ho-oh's sacred fire is now stronger than lugia's aeroblast.
Of course I wouldn't expose such an argument if they weren't the only pokemons able to learn those moves...
Ho-oh's base attack:130
Lugia's base SpAttack:90

dnguyen
offline
dnguyen
614 posts
Nomad

Ho-oh's base attack:130
Lugia's base SpAttack:90


Yeah, I agree, but I care about defense.

Lugia Base Defense: 130
Ho-oh Base Defense: 90

130>90
FallenSky
offline
FallenSky
1,813 posts
Peasant

Yeah but if I want a fortress, I won't go with Lugia...
Maybe Bronzong or even shuckle...
I already leveled a shuckle up to 100 and it was nigh unstoppable^^

dnguyen
offline
dnguyen
614 posts
Nomad

Yeah but if I want a fortress, I won't go with Lugia...
Maybe Bronzong or even shuckle...
I already leveled a shuckle up to 100 and it was nigh unstoppable^^


You know what, you're right, even if Ho-oh or Lugia protects themselves, they'll still die. If a Shuckle protects himselfs, it's unstoppable
Pazx
offline
Pazx
5,845 posts
Peasant

Groudon>Kyogre? I said that out of personal preference, which is basically what this whole thread is about.

Yeah, the pokemon exclusive to HG are cool, and there are more if I am correct, but my brother has HG so I'm not worried.

dnguyen
offline
dnguyen
614 posts
Nomad

Groudon>Kyogre? I said that out of personal preference, which is basically what this whole thread is about.


I know that, it's just that it shows something u know
comictragedy
offline
comictragedy
4 posts
Nomad

Pokemon is amazing. I'd like to have a bubble bath with all of my pokemon.

What happens in the bubbles, STAYS in the bubbles.

Showing 46-60 of 91