ForumsArt, Music, and WritingKingJac's Writings

26 5459
kingjac11
offline
kingjac11
2,597 posts
Nomad

I am going to post poems. A critique and feedback would be appreciated!

His Fate
His aim was true,
Pierced through their bodies,
The arrows short and narrow.

Not one or two but three he slay,
As every arrow flew,
They came upon him,
Hit and stabbed and poke and prodded.

But because of his bravery,
They couldn't reach,
His family in time,
He to them was their most noble protector.

His body lay their for maybe a week,
Then they came and took it away,
On a boat and sent down the river.

Battle Victor
The battle horn cries.
See them clash together.
One mans sword through another mans leather.
He falls to the ground,Without another sound.

They are the winners,They are the best.
They are the champions,They are Victors.
But does it really matter,all those victories.
Why must they fight,a fight that isn't theirs.

  • 26 Replies
GlimmeringStars
offline
GlimmeringStars
95 posts
Nomad

These are pretty good, Jac.
The flow seemed to be off a little but other than that they were alright.
Try to make the sentences around the same length, it'll flow better.

kingjac11
offline
kingjac11
2,597 posts
Nomad

I made this in the first line poetry thread.

I feel like I'm gonna die,
My life has been a lie,
Tossed around like a piece of trash,
I see a bright flash.

I feel my heart beating,
We are retreating,
I hurry away,
But I only get halfway...

SupaLegit
offline
SupaLegit
644 posts
Nomad

I feel like I'm gonna die,
My life has been a lie,
Tossed around like a piece of trash,
I see a bright flash.

I feel my heart beating,
We are retreating,
I hurry away,
But I only get halfway...

Pretty decent poem, jac!
I like how although it rhymed, it wasn't overdone.

On this particular stanza of Battle Victor,
They are the winners,They are the best.
They are the champions,They are Victors.
But does it really matter,all those victories.
Why must they fight,a fight that isn't theirs.

seems a tad bit off...

I would suggest this form:

They are the winners,
They are the best;
They are the champions,
They are victors.

But all those victories,
Does it really matter?
Why must they fight
A fight that isn't theirs?

It flows better, and appeals to the eye a bit more in my opinion.
Maverick4
offline
Maverick4
6,800 posts
Peasant

But because of his bravery,
They couldn't reach,
His family in time,
He to them was their most noble protector.


The enjabment is off in this one. Other than that, the poem is pretty good. Still reminds me of Boromir... :P

I feel my heart beating,
We are retreating,
I hurry away,
But I only get halfway...


This poem is honestly my favorite. It flows really well, until the last line, which is jsut slightly off somehow. Dunno what really, but just experiment with differen't wordings and such. Keep submitting more for review, and you'll get better. Keep it up.
kingjac11
offline
kingjac11
2,597 posts
Nomad

It flows better, and appeals to the eye a bit more in my opinion
Oh I see that.

Wind
Wind in my hair,
Flying through the air,
Shouting,Screaming,Crying,
Can't believe I'm Flying

A quick one I made.
kingjac11
offline
kingjac11
2,597 posts
Nomad

Bullets
Bullets flying,
Men dying,
Groans of pain,
Bodies lain.


Soldiers running,
Enemies gunning,
Bullets hit,
People Split.

Maverick4
offline
Maverick4
6,800 posts
Peasant

'Wind' was pretty humorous I thought.

Bullets is ok. The rhyming is pretty simple, though it works. The flow gets cut at the line 'Enemies gunning'. What happened is that this had too many sylabuls compared to the other lines. I would suggest something like 'Foes are gunning', so it works a bit better. It helps if you say the poem outloud a few times, and trying differen't connotations for the words, and switching around.

Good job overall, and I look foreward to more.

Masterforger
offline
Masterforger
1,824 posts
Peasant

A rod of iron, in the flame is transfigured and is no more. one can never return unchanged from the Forge.

From the sermon of st. Edgar.

kingjac11
offline
kingjac11
2,597 posts
Nomad

Made for the ten day contest:
Little Wooden House
Try to remember,
The little wooden house,
Where the old man lived.
Try to remember,
How the house was burnt to crisp,
While he slept the time away.
Try to remember,
How he hurried to the door,
fumbling with the keys.
Try to remember,
His daring escape,
Dancing with death.
Come and see the ashes,
Can you help build it up?
Help us rise it from the ashes,
For his wifes sake.

kingjac11
offline
kingjac11
2,597 posts
Nomad

Made in the first line poetry thread.
Fish and sharks, attack that tablecloth!
Snapping at my feet,
Jumping from the floor,
I scream and shout,
Looking for help.

SupaLegit
offline
SupaLegit
644 posts
Nomad

I think it would appeal more and perhaps flow a bit better if it were broken into stanzas, but that is just me:

Little Wooden House
Try to remember
The little wooden house,
Where the old man lived.

Try to remember
How the house was burnt to crisp,
While he slept the time away.

Try to remember
How he hurried to the door,
fumbling with the keys.

Try to remember
His daring escape,
Dancing with death.

Come and see the ashes,
Can you help build it up?
Help us rise it from the ashes,
For his wife's sake.


Besides the form of the poem:


Help us rise it from the ashes,
For his wife's sake.


Disappointed me as the reader in some regard. The beginning was nice, dark, and awesome, but at the end, you make it into a sort of joke at the end.

Oh, yes,
Come and see the ashes,
Can you help build it up?
Help us rise it from the ashes,

Very confusing in some regard. At first you want us to see the ashes, and want us to rebuild (amusing) him by his ashes. BUt then you say help us rise it from the ashes... Rise what from the ashes? His ashes? That makes no sense.

Lastly, I think you could have came up with a better title, like "Remember" or something of the sort, as that is truly what the poem is about: 'Remember and Rise'.

Other than the stuff listed above, great job, my favorite part is this part:
Try to remember,
How he hurried to the door,
fumbling with the keys.
Try to remember,
His daring escape,
Dancing with death
SupaLegit
offline
SupaLegit
644 posts
Nomad

Oh yeah after Remember i would use a colon : 'cause your listing... Like so:

Try to remember:
How he hurried to the door,
fumbling with the keys.


~Now for the first line poetry one...

Fish and sharks, attack that tablecloth!
Snapping at my feet,
Jumping from the floor,
I scream and shout,
Looking for help.

First off, great job, using that line that I would personally never use. It seems a bit... lame in my opinion.

My only concern is, that first line is GREATLY larger than the others, two times larger, in fact. Either keep it at a similar length, or steadily increase/decrease length would make it appeal to the eye a tad bit more.
kingjac11
offline
kingjac11
2,597 posts
Nomad

I couldn't decrease the lent because that was the line I had to use.

SupaLegit
offline
SupaLegit
644 posts
Nomad

That is OK, I'm just saying the other lines could have been a bit longer, so that they are closer in length. An easy way to have done that is by adding some detail (adjective/adverbs).

kingjac11
offline
kingjac11
2,597 posts
Nomad

Fish and sharks, attack that tablecloth!
Snapping at my feet,with their sharp teeth,
Jumping from the floor,I cant run for the door,
I've screamed and shouted,I begin to doubt,
Looking for help,So desperate I begin to yelp.


Better?

Showing 1-15 of 26