I'd probably have to say F.E.A.R. Resident Evil isn't as scary as it use to be. Nazi Zombies as tennisman said are pretty scary (especially at 12 A.M.), Dead Space is a lot of psycological and Resident Evil is scary as they are overwhelming you, an Bioshock? Out of the question. Good game, but it really isn't scray and when you figure out you have infinite respawns it just is total fun with the wrench.
yeha i would say dead space because it seems like a horror movie as your playin it and u know if u walk out and theres like alot of them your pretty much screwed unless you rlucky that or maybe like manhunt 2 or somting ive never playedit but it looks scary or bloodshot whatever the new one it looks scray to
i didnt play enouhg of fear 2 fo it to scare me but im gonna hire it again so i can play it because it was a good game but i would say the scariest would have to be dead space that was a good game
I'd say F.E.A.R. but there are other games scarier than this. Let me tell you something about Dead Space. Why is that spaceship all painted grey and black? And someone put flickering lights everywhere as much as possible. Let Yahtzee tell you about it. http://www.escapistmagazine.com/videos/view/zero-punctuation/333-Dead-Space Copy-paste.