ForumsThe TavernIs a plane more dangerous than a car?

226 45124
grebdews
offline
grebdews
112 posts
Nomad

No, that is ridiculous.
You mess up in a plane, you go doun.
You mess up in a car, 7 people go down.
You mess up in a plane, you have 3,000 feet to catch yourself
You mess up in a car well...
Your engine fails in a plane, you glide to earth.
Your engine fails on earth you crash.
Anybody can get a licence, but a pilot's licence takes hours of flight time.
In a car, there is no control tower...

  • 226 Replies
the_manta
offline
the_manta
4,535 posts
Peasant

Well, on the very rare occasion that one crashes, more people die in a plane crash, but something has to go horribly awry for the plane to crash, and it's very unlikely.

So driving, technically.

Funfax: in a test comparing people under the influence and people texting while driving, the drunks actually did better.

So stop texting whilst you drive.

orfict
offline
orfict
124 posts
Nomad

Planes are more dangerous. The fact that more people die in car accidents shouldnt be involved. Cars were around longer.

kyocat64
offline
kyocat64
657 posts
Nomad

Planes are way safer. More ppl die each year by shark attacks then in airplane accidents.

stefaan
offline
stefaan
44 posts
Bard

cars are less dangerous

howdydo
offline
howdydo
62 posts
Nomad

i heard that cars are more dangerous because you can crash but i dont belive it what happens if a planes engine runs out.....

Kasic
offline
Kasic
5,546 posts
Jester

Depends on the situtation. As in more deaths per year, cars DEFINITELY win. However, in a car crash, you have a better chance of surviving than if a plane crashed. Fortunately, planes do not crash very often, and my dad is a pilot, and i've seen what they do and all the avoidance and backup systems, and i'd have to go with cars are 10000 times more dangerous on average.

cenation
offline
cenation
96 posts
Nomad

personally i think airplanes are much much more safe.

alot more people die in car crashes and they happen like every seceond.

plus on a plane the pilot knows how to fix the problem really fast, and plane crashes don't happen that often.

Kasic
offline
Kasic
5,546 posts
Jester

alot more people die in car crashes and they happen like every seceond.


Heh, that's because it's extremely easy to get a drivers license but you actually need to be trained as a pilot AND then trained on THAT AIRPLANE SPECIFICALLY. Each pilot that flies the plane spends at least a month learning everything about it, basic controls, back up systems, everything. All you need to do for a license is drive with an instructor for 30 minutes and boom there you go, another driver that shouldn't be driving is on the road.
XVERB
offline
XVERB
3,137 posts
Nomad

Kasic i agree but a plane is a very complex piece of equipment and if it were as easy to drive as a car then every one could be i pilot.

SirNoobalot
offline
SirNoobalot
22,207 posts
Nomad

the problem is by 'gliding' to earth who says you won't hit something? and not all car crashes are fatal. it isnt automatically guaranteed you will die if you crash in a car.

MarioMario
offline
MarioMario
1,212 posts
Peasant

I am not sure.See in a plane you risk like 200 lives if some thing goes wrong and then you flip and then get shot down by star wars people (trust me it happens)

German3945
offline
German3945
996 posts
Nomad

the problem is by 'gliding' to earth who says you won't hit something?

the statistics do. car wrecks are exponentially more likely than plane wrecks.
and not all car crashes are fatal.

not all plane crashes are fatal. one article sites a study in which 69 percent of passengers survived plane crashes.
"The odds of being killed in a plane crash are about 1 in 11 million."

"Your lifetime probability of dying in a motor accident [is] about 1 in 83."
Pau11Wa11
offline
Pau11Wa11
527 posts
Nomad

probly cars due to total death counts in car vs plane crashes but they can both be equally dangerous, depending on the scenario

German3945
offline
German3945
996 posts
Nomad

I didn't mean to quote some part of my post. kind of screwed that up.
correction:

Not all plane crashes are fatal. One article sties a study in which 69 percent of passengers survived plane crashes.
Regarding probability of crashes:
"The odds of being killed in a plane crash are about 1 in 11 million."
"Your lifetime probability of dying in a motor accident [is] about 1 in 83."

Kasic
offline
Kasic
5,546 posts
Jester

Kasic i agree but a plane is a very complex piece of equipment and if it were as easy to drive as a car then every one could be i pilot.


True, but in all actuality the flying part isn't the hardest, it's knowing the equipment, switches and controls, just about anyone can keep the plane in the air at least.

Your engine fails in a plane, you glide to earth.


From what I know, most planes can still fly on one engine. As for the gliding part, that isn't quite accurate. The plane itself is too heavy to just glide and keep a decent amount of lift, it's the vaccuum the occurs over the wing that gives the plane lift, not the air resistance under the wing. You can't glide well in a comercial jet. That's why you need a lot of speed to fly, if it were just the air under the wing you wouldn't need to go half as fast to get lift.
Showing 136-150 of 226