ForumsThe TavernRugby vs American football

59 9280
Blkasp
offline
Blkasp
1,303 posts
Nomad

Post your comments here, this is a debate so post decent reasons!

  • 59 Replies
PossibleInstability
offline
PossibleInstability
975 posts
Nomad

Things that amazes me are that a lot of people like that there's no pads in Rugby, and think that Amer. Football is a wimpy game because they take timeouts and rest in between plays, and because of that Rugby is a "mans" game. I'd rather like to know that my body is going to be protected from hard hits rather than breaking a shoulder or sternum, hip or leg. The reason why there's breaks in between is because of play calling. Pads and breaks for play calling doesn't make for a "wimpy" game it makes for a good strategic game were players can hit as hard as they can and know that they're protected and don't have to worry about getting seriously injured.


...Rugby is still better.
gamingamer
offline
gamingamer
77 posts
Nomad

GOOOOOOOOOOOOOO FOOOOOOOTBAAAAAAAAAALLL!!!!!!

ucfKnights
offline
ucfKnights
28 posts
Nomad

Heard this earlier today on espn, Rugby and Golf will be added to the 2016 Olympics. They'll be men's and women's competition for both sports.

So what got the axe: baseball, softball, squash, karate, and roller sports. Anyone have any idea what they mean by roller sports?

As for the topic, I prefer American Football to Rugby but I gotta respect people playing Rugby, takes some big brass ones to play that sport.

Thyll
offline
Thyll
476 posts
Nomad

I prefer Football, but Rugby is a good game too. I love playing, but not watching. I don't understand what enjoyment people get from watching 300 pound 6 feet tall men hurl themselves at each other. I don't know them, I don't care about them. Do it if you want, but I'm not gonna support your 10 million dollar paychecks.

XVERB
offline
XVERB
3,137 posts
Nomad

Anyone have any idea what they mean by roller sports?


biking? i would say skateboarding but i don't think thats even in there.

as for the topic i think i would like rugby better but the problem is no one in the U.S. actually plays it. so by defalt i choose American Football (go redskins!!)
delossantosj
offline
delossantosj
6,672 posts
Nomad

lol ok once again im going to have to give on of my speeches on why football is better then rugby.

football has padding which means that the players are safer. and last time a checked more dangorous doesnt mean better.

while rugby may be more fast paced yes football players are in much better shape then most of the people in the world.
football players run faster, bench more, squat more, deadlift more, and pretty much are overall more powerfull in everyway to rugby players.

foot ball plays are the most complex of any sport in the world. rugby is mildly simple and i learned it in a matter of 5 minutes of watching it on tv lol.

when people say that foot ball is a bunch of fat heads running around for no reason, its quite the other way around. rugby players dont exactly have plays. they mindlessly run around trying to score.

rugby is less safe, the players are less athletic, and football is much more strategic in every way. if one player messes up, quarter back gets sacked.

football is actually one of the more deffinitional sports then any.

football mixes strategy with athleticism and you actually have to think to play it. quarter backs are extremely stressed for if they throw one bad ball they may have lost the entire game. and i have high high high respects for them

knight_34
offline
knight_34
13,817 posts
Farmer

I've noticed that this subject has a tendency towards bias.

Anyway, I've found something rather good. Before anyone's opinion is to be respectable, I want them to have played and experienced both sports. They aren't exactly the same.

delossantosj
offline
delossantosj
6,672 posts
Nomad

i experience rugby alot especially since high school cause my girl friend's brother plays rugby

knight_34
offline
knight_34
13,817 posts
Farmer

I think it is already obvious that you have bias towards gridiron football. I want to hear someone who has actually played both sports, and has been to countries where both sports are popular.

delossantosj
offline
delossantosj
6,672 posts
Nomad

isnt american football only popular in america though

knight_34
offline
knight_34
13,817 posts
Farmer

Yes, but that does not refute what I said.

Get someone who has played gridiron football in America, and rugby in one of the rugby popular countries.

delossantosj
offline
delossantosj
6,672 posts
Nomad

thats going to be a hard find. but to me safer in sports is better

fizeau2
offline
fizeau2
25 posts
Nomad

Rugby is way more fun to play, but i don't watch it. I would rather watch Football over Rugby if for no other reason then i understand it.
Maybe if Rugby was more popular in the U.S. i would watch it more.

Showing 46-58 of 59