ForumsThe TavernIs a plane more dangerous than a car?

226 45119
grebdews
offline
grebdews
112 posts
Nomad

No, that is ridiculous.
You mess up in a plane, you go doun.
You mess up in a car, 7 people go down.
You mess up in a plane, you have 3,000 feet to catch yourself
You mess up in a car well...
Your engine fails in a plane, you glide to earth.
Your engine fails on earth you crash.
Anybody can get a licence, but a pilot's licence takes hours of flight time.
In a car, there is no control tower...

  • 226 Replies
grebdews
offline
grebdews
112 posts
Nomad

Face it way more people die from cars. Cars are more dangerous!!!!!

knight_34
offline
knight_34
13,817 posts
Farmer

I am never going on a Qantas plane again.


That's what they all say.

Statistically, cars are more dangerous. We all know that.

Though my point is that on a case-by-case basis, plane crashes are much more dangerous than car accidents. Yes, every day we have someone dying on the road but I have to say plane crashes startle and attract attention more. They're scarier.
manny6574
offline
manny6574
922 posts
Nomad

way more people die from cars. Cars are more dangerous!!!!!


100% true, the thing is, all the dangerous stuff about planes, is because many people die at once!
hynjie
offline
hynjie
260 posts
Nomad

more people die from car accidents than plane accidents ya know

GhostGS
offline
GhostGS
323 posts
Nomad

cars will always be more dangerous... lets get this straight
which is more accessible? cars
which requires the least amount of experience? 120 hours for a normal car then 3 years of practice until full license. a plane 30 hours until license to fly solo.. 300hrs until commericial license
which are more common? cars
there are more cars on the road then there are planes in the air...
the only reason it is tragetic to hear a plane crash is usually because it doesn't occur often and when it does many ppl are injured.. whereas car incidients occur more frequently and vary in consequences... a small scratch to a head on collision with a tree. we only hear car crashes on the news when it is usually when a death occurs

vontje
offline
vontje
866 posts
Nomad

I think that a car is more dangerous, because there are a lot of people who are drunk and who still drive, that isn't possible in a plane, a pilot would be fired immediately! and you have joyriders, i don't think you have that on a plane..

so i think a car is more dangerous! also because there are more cars on a road, so 2 cars who bang into each other is more likely than two planes.

MRWalker82
offline
MRWalker82
4,005 posts
Shepherd

Cars are infinitely more dangerous. They require the least amount of training to operate, the least amount of maintenance to be brought out on our streets, they operate in highly congested environments with thousands of opportunities for life threatening errors to occur in even a simple 15 minute commute.

On the other hand aircraft operate in largely unoccupied areas with little to no chance for collision, they are maintained and monitored to extreme safety standards, and their operators are rigorously trained and monitored.

The reason that there is so much controversy over aircraft malfunctions is two fold. Firstly, a malfunction leading to an accident is an extremely rare occurrence. Secondly, a serious accident typically involves the death or injury of hundreds of people, whereas your typical fatal car crash involves 1-4 injuries and/or fatalities.

br0seph
offline
br0seph
33 posts
Nomad

a car is MUCH more dangerous that a plane. I would go into details but the earlier comments have said it all.

slayguy8
offline
slayguy8
718 posts
Peasant

planes are safer but if there is a crash more people die

mdv96
offline
mdv96
1,017 posts
Nomad

statistically, you are way more likely to die on a train than on any other form of transportation...
Cars are more dangerous because everyday you hear of a accident or even a death on the roadways. A plan crash is rare and few have occurred recently.

SubZero131
offline
SubZero131
598 posts
Nomad

well, do planes have drunk drivers? if people have drove a plane drunk that is sad.
but car crashes, i see sever a year just near my house, and i hear a few ambulances go by every day. although not all of them are for car accidents i am sure

2014631
offline
2014631
1,855 posts
Nomad

Well everyone talks about how rare it is to die in a plane crash. There's soooo many more cars than planes!

doules
offline
doules
16 posts
Nomad

Planes are safer because there are more cars driving than there are planes in the sky in the same routes. And also a pilot cant get drunk and fly a plane and you need more work to fly a plane. Except for engine failure or something and terrorists

2014631
offline
2014631
1,855 posts
Nomad

a pilot cant get drunk


anyone can get drunk. Pilots have gotten drunk before. And one loose bolt on a plane and it can take the whole thing down. Cars, not so much.
MRWalker82
offline
MRWalker82
4,005 posts
Shepherd

Interesting compilation of information from Crash Stuff.com here. It's a breakdown of per mile vehicular accidents separating motor vehicle travel, commercial aviation, and general aviation (private, not for profit pilots/personal aircraft)

Choosing âmile to mileâ as the more appropriate comparison for differing modes of transportation (and overlooking that small planes often takeoff and land at the same airport, without ever really âgoing anywhereâ), letâs review the fatality rates:

driving: 1.32 fatal accidents and 1.47 fatalities per 100 million miles

airlines: .05 fatal accidents and 1.57 fatalities per 100 million miles

GA: 7.46 fatal accidents and 13.1 fatalities per 100 million miles


Obviously we see that even on a per mile basis commercial airlines are by far the safest way to travel, and flying with your buddy who just got his pilot's license probably isn't so smart

Showing 196-210 of 226