ForumsThe TavernIs a plane more dangerous than a car?

226 45120
grebdews
offline
grebdews
112 posts
Nomad

No, that is ridiculous.
You mess up in a plane, you go doun.
You mess up in a car, 7 people go down.
You mess up in a plane, you have 3,000 feet to catch yourself
You mess up in a car well...
Your engine fails in a plane, you glide to earth.
Your engine fails on earth you crash.
Anybody can get a licence, but a pilot's licence takes hours of flight time.
In a car, there is no control tower...

  • 226 Replies
howlett
offline
howlett
2,278 posts
Nomad

I think a plane is more dangerous than a car, but there are far more car crashes to plane ones, so it could go either way, but planes, I don't like, just really nervous when I am on one...

IgnoreMe
offline
IgnoreMe
184 posts
Nomad

I think a plane is more dangerous because there are a lot more people riding a plane then a car but, there are more car accidents then plane so I think both are dangerous.

MRWalker82
offline
MRWalker82
4,005 posts
Shepherd

Just fyi, if you travel the same mileage in a car as a passenger in a commercial airline you are nearly 27x more likely to be in a fatal accident in a car. Think about that the next time you plan on going on a road trip as opposed to flying.

CommanderDude7
offline
CommanderDude7
4,689 posts
Nomad

Suddenly I have the urge to buy a helicopter instead of a car. Since apparently cars are that dangerous.

27x more likely to be in a fatal accident in a car

*gasps*
1984chevy
offline
1984chevy
225 posts
Nomad

It is easier to survive a car crash

Google567
offline
Google567
4,013 posts
Farmer

Well its easier to get killed in a plane crash.

synallday
offline
synallday
49 posts
Nomad

a plane is less dangerous i believe because your don't run into drunk plane drivers... well i guess you could but that is nearly immpossiable and planes are constantly checked for flaws unlike cars

liamster3
offline
liamster3
140 posts
Nomad

a car is more dangerous more people die in car crash then a plane crash every year

DarkGamer99
offline
DarkGamer99
606 posts
Nomad

I agree, Cars are way more dangerous than planes.

fella001
offline
fella001
11 posts
Nomad

It depends if there is a good pilot in a plane and if there is a good driver in a car.

brp47
offline
brp47
580 posts
Peasant

to drive a plane u need years of experience and regular updates and testing to see if you still have the ability (good)

to drive a car you need to be 17 and to do 1 test and in some countrys you can just buy a liscence (bad)

basically ur more likely to be run over by a chav

cleofer5
offline
cleofer5
354 posts
Scribe

neither is more deadly, but the situation you put yourself in. You dont HAVE to be in a car with a drunk driver. You dont HAVE to drive at night when your tired. But thats what people do and they die! Plus hundreds of people die a year in plane crashes. I mean landing or even flying a plane is not easy and two is recommended. If one person passes out it still is a lot of pressure on the other person as they have lives to save, and sometimes they know they cant do anything.

ShonaFurey
offline
ShonaFurey
67 posts
Nomad

I don't know wether this has made me feel safer or more fearful to fly.

I say planes are more dangerous. Not due to statstics that can prove otherwise, but because of the fear factors. You'll meet millions with a plane pobia and very little with a car phobia. I travel a lot by plane and it scares me everytime, although fireflys pilot talk is reassuring.

Cenere
offline
Cenere
13,656 posts
Jester

What... Why...
WHO NECROED THIS D:<
This had already been out-debated to the end of the world and back, why...

Whatever, locked.

Showing 211-224 of 226