Forums → Art, Music, and Writing → [necro] Picture Changing Contest (judging posted on page 19)
| 284 | 61159 |
- 284 Replies
Great job everyone! Here are the ratings/comments for each picture!
GuitarHeroFtw
Moat: 5/10 - I hate to be rough on you with my rating. But you hardly changed this one at all. Nothing but the lure was changed, and although I do admire your humor in that, I think you could've done far better. Far better
Fluffy: 3/10 - uhh... that isn't very different. At all. >.>
TSL: 5.5/10 - All in all it was very bland, and not a lot of creativity. It did however make me lawl, so I gave it points. Not the greatest.
Average picture rating: 4.5
Jdoggparty
Moat: 8/10 - Very good, but could've been better. A little too bright on the eyes, and let's be honest, it wouldn't have taken that much effort or time to make.
Fluffy: 8/10 - Awesome job with the Heat Map effect! The colors look very good together, with the red backround and all.
TSL: 7/10 - I definitely liked the thermal image type look, as well as the curvy type antennae. The graphic level however seemed to drop. Pretty good if I say so myself.
Average picture rating: 7.6
Thisisnotanalt
Moat: 9/10 - I liked it a lot! Very pretty, much different from the original, and very nice to look at. Also, you can tell that this one took some real effort.
Fluffy: 8/10 - Very nice. Nice contrasting colors.
TSL: 8.5/10 - Very colorful, definitely my favorite. I like the patterns on the 'wall' behind it. It makes me think that it's a painting on a wall. Truly a great edit. Makes me wish I had photoshop.
Average picture rating: 8.5
Ligaboy
Moat: 6.5/10 - Well, I can tell that took some time and effort, and it is epically weirdified. But in my opinion, it just doesn't look good at all. It's blurred to death and a mess of pixels and bright light.
Fluffy: 9/10 - The colorless effect makes the picture look almost unreal, I think it's my favorite.
TSL: 7.5/10 - While very bland, the effect is magnificent. It's almost like I'm looking through some glass in space. Very good.
Average picture rating: 7.73
Cholokid
Moat: 7.5/10 - Although this clearly didn't take much effort(didn't do anything but invert colors, yeah?)it looks very good. Although I think you could have done better with the colors; the fish tends to kind of blur into the white background, and it's a bit too bright on the eyes.
Fluffy: 4/10 - Not very interesting, it didn't look like it took very much effort. but still kinda looks cool. >.<
TSL: 5/10 - As he said yay, I said nay. The only effect I see in it is an invert. Not very creative. Doesn't look very good either.
Average picture rating: 5.5
Parrot657
Moat: 3/10 - And I repeat the reasons why Guitarheroftw's got a low rating as well:But you hardly changed this one at all. Nothing but the lure was changed. And you get less points than he does because I at least gave him humor and originality. You as well as copied him.
Fluffy: 6/10 - Lol. It kinda makes me laugh cause' it just looks like the fish is just staring crazily at it, lol. 6/10 for funniness/creativity. Just next time, try to put more effort into it. You know this contest is called the Picture Changing Contest.
TSL: 6.5/10 - Very good, nice creativity. Also quite funny. Nothing other than that stands out.
Average picture rating: 5.16
Crimsonblade55
Moat: 7/10 - Not bad. I like the cool color schematic and especially the bloody teeth,and a fair amount of effort was put into it. But it still could've been better
I guess I'll update as new submissions are added, eh?
Fluffy: 7/10 - Pretty cool. But this contest is called, once again, The Picture Changing Contest.
TSL: /10 - N/A sry :/
Average picture rating: 7
Fluffy: GREAT JOB! Everyone's pictures are really, really, awesome. Pure awesomeness in this thread. Sorry for posting so early but I can't go on tomorrow or the next day. Sorry for no merit reward but you get to be on my profile!
Moat: All in all, everyone put in a great effort and a great picture and it was very difficult to make my decisions! I hope that my well-intended criticism doesn't come off too strong, and that it helps you TWIST better pictures. I also hope you had a good time participating in the Picture Changing Contest, and whoever wins, everyone's pictures pwn. This coming from someone who TWISTS pictures often as well.
1st place: Thisisnotanalt
2nd place: Ligaboy
3rd place: Jdogg
AWESOME JOB!