ForumsWEPRRussia or China?

66 8966
jonnypants23
offline
jonnypants23
1,353 posts
Farmer

There has benn many America verse another nation but I just wanted to know , who do you think would have victorie Russia or China ?

  • 66 Replies
Reptillian
offline
Reptillian
24 posts
Nomad

I think in the end, Russia would win.

Simply because i think the U.S. would be dragged in, and we would side with Russia.

miguelin11
offline
miguelin11
2,905 posts
Nomad

i'd choose neither of them. But if I was FORCED to choose it would be russia. china just s-u-c-k

Communist
offline
Communist
522 posts
Nomad

wtf soviet union isnt russia

um yes it is? it's on the exact same location; minus the baltics and Afghanistan. ( It's now the Russian Federation)
woody_7007
offline
woody_7007
2,662 posts
Peasant

um no it isnt, regardless of its geographical location it is now the Russian Federation. The United Soviet Socialist Republic or Soviet Union included many other countries like East Germany, Ukraine many other Eastern European and Baltic states. Russia actually lost the war in Afghanistan quite spectacularly once the Afghans were given the right weaponry.

thedemonlord
offline
thedemonlord
26 posts
Nomad

I reckon russia would win because they would have more countries side with them.

Though i wouldn't have thought the would have a war anyway.

russianfreak
offline
russianfreak
1,843 posts
Farmer

woody_7007 is right it isn't russia but russia was the biggest influence to the U.S.S.R. so ya and russia would whin cause not a lot of people would like to have communism in the world and that means us and england and india and all the other big forces of the world combined would kick chinas ass so ya i mean russia would win.

jonnypants23
offline
jonnypants23
1,353 posts
Farmer

Without a context, it is impossible to say


Im asking for oppions.
crazjayz
offline
crazjayz
243 posts
Nomad

Wow, I'm surprised many of you are saying that Russia would win if they were in a war with China. Just looking at the statistics cited by woody_7007 you can see that China has the possibility of a greater army (number wise), more financial backing, a larger labor force, all with less land area to defend. ChopstickBoB has already stated the historical factor of China invading Russia, and the chinese advantage of defending a smaller amount of land with more people. I'll touch on the other aspects of war, especially in this day and age, just like Parsat brought up. But instead of looking at allies or generals, I'm just going to look at the economy of these two countries. Frankly speaking, Russia could not afford a war with China. Just looking at GDP purchasing power parity (citing the CIA World Factbook), China has 7.1 trillion US dollars, while Russia has just 2.1 trillion. Moreover, China's market value of publicly traded shares is at 4.5 trillion Us Dollars, while Russia is only at 1.3 trillion US Dollars. Finally, the "true market value" of the Renminbi yuan (RMB) is not actually known, since estimations of China's internal economy are hazy at best. Russia's economy is clearly known by all countries, and while it has been steadly growing at about 7% per annum, that's no where near China's "double digit economic growth" and stated 400% increase in the past 10 years.

Simply state, if Russia and China were to go at war with each other, all China would have to do is keep the war going long enough where Russia would become stagnate and eventually run out of money.

thedemonlord
offline
thedemonlord
26 posts
Nomad

Yes but like i said people would side with Russia and help them so if they were low on money their allies would help them.

_S_K_E_
offline
_S_K_E_
731 posts
Nomad

Russia is the best country for war and it has a lot of nukes but we can beat China, I know it!

jonnypants23
offline
jonnypants23
1,353 posts
Farmer

Russia is the best country for war and it has a lot of nukes but we can beat China


Do you have any facts to back your statement up?
russianfreak
offline
russianfreak
1,843 posts
Farmer

Russia is the best country for war and it has a lot of nukes but we can beat China
Do you have any facts to back your statement up?

i do they have over 30 nukes wich means they can blow up all of chinas main places were they manufacture tanks and wepons to bad and then china will be pointless against russia and did you see what russia did to georgia they just blew up evrything they needed and now georgia is helpless same thing gonna happin to china
ChopstickBoB
offline
ChopstickBoB
142 posts
Nomad

I think in the end, Russia would win.
Simply because i think the U.S. would be dragged in, and we would side with Russia.


Not directly. The US economy is to entagled in China's to directly oppose them. Perhaps with intelligence and strategic satalite resources. The US, along with NATO, would most likely side with whoever was declared war on.

Simply state, if Russia and China were to go at war with each other, all China would have to do is keep the war going long enough where Russia would become stagnate and eventually run out of money.


Good point, but they would most likely be able to borrow the money neccesary to keep a war going on indefinately, assuming they are not the aggressors. A declaration of war on China's part would also most likely result in heavy trade sanctions on them, evening up the economic imbalance.
Yakooza99K
offline
Yakooza99K
588 posts
Nomad

i do they have over 30 nukes wich means they can blow up all of chinas main places were they manufacture tanks and wepons to bad and then china will be pointless against russia and did you see what russia did to georgia they just blew up evrything they needed and now georgia is helpless same thing gonna happin to china


30? Russia has thousands, so does america


btw, this is what would happen

America would fund both sides, then it would step in at the very end and push China back, then take all the credit.
Zyko
offline
Zyko
17 posts
Nomad

When Bush was a president, everything was going not to war China/Russia but to war China & Russia/USA.
We'll se what Obama will do.
P.S. I think Russia would win

Showing 16-30 of 66